FraudBadNo taxation without receipts

Agency

Department of Homeland Security

Department of Homeland Security has reported $6.7B in improper and unverifiable payments across 50 programs since fiscal 2006, by our sum of its own reports. In fiscal 2025: $274M.

Paid wrong, year by year

All of DHS's reporting programs combined, each fiscal year. Bars link to that year.

Every program it has reported

ProgramLatest yearWrong or unprovenRateYears reported
Validate as You GoFederal Emergency Management Agency - Public AssistanceFY2025$260M1.2%5
Funeral AssistanceFederal Emergency Management AgencyFY2025$13M4.3%2
Disaster Supplemental FundsImmigration and Customs Enforcement - Procurement, Construction, and ImprovementsFY2025<$1M0.2%1
Disaster Supplemental FundsUnited States Customs and Border Protection - Procurement, Construction, and ImprovementsFY2024$00.0%2
Disaster Supplemental FundsFederal Emergency Management Agency - Hazard Mitigation Grant ProgramFY2023<$1M0.9%2
Disaster Supplemental FundsFederal Emergency Management Agency - PayrollFY2022$7M2.9%3
Disaster Supplemental FundsFederal Emergency Management Agency - Vendor PayFY2022$3M0.7%1
Disaster Supplemental FundsFederal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) - Disaster Case ManagementFY2022$1M1.7%3
Disaster Supplemental FundsUnited States Coast Guard - Procurements, Construction, and ImprovementFY2022<$1M0.6%2
Disaster Supplemental FundsUnited States Coast Guard - Aviation Logistics CommandFY2022$00.0%2
Disaster Supplemental FundsFederal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) - Disaster Relief Fund (DRF): Individuals and Households ProgramFY2021$6M4.8%2
Disaster Supplemental FundsFederal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) - Urban Search and RescueFY2021$3M18.7%2
Disaster Supplemental FundsU.S. Customs and Border Protection (CBP) - Operations & SupportFY2021$2M8.7%2
Disaster Supplemental FundsFederal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) - Commercial Bill of LadingFY2021<$1M3.6%2
Disaster Supplemental FundsFederal Emergency Management Agency (FEMA) - TravelFY2021<$1M0.6%2
Disaster Supplemental FundsOffice of Inspector General (OIG) - Audits, Inspections, & InvestigationsFY2021<$1M2.2%1
Disaster Supplemental FundsUnited States Coast Guard - Operations & SupportFY2021<$1M1.0%2
Vendor PayFederal Emergency Management AgencyFY2020$27M1.2%9
Federal Protective ServiceManagement DirectorateFY2020$4M1.9%8
Disaster Supplemental FundsImmigration and Customs Enforcement (ICE) - Operations & SupportFY2020$00.0%1
Public AssistanceFederal Emergency Management AgencyFY2019$27M0.7%11
National Flood Insurance ProgramFEMAFY2019<$1M0.0%11
Flood Hazard Map and Risk Analysis ProgramFederal Emergency Management AgencyFY2019<$1M0.0%5
Homeland Security Grant ProgramFederal Emergency Management AgencyFY2018$6M0.7%10
Assistance to Firefighter GrantsFederal Emergency Management AgencyFY2018$4M1.3%10
Refund and DrawbackUnited States Customs and Border ProtectionFY2018<$1M0.0%12
Enforcement and Removal OperationsImmigration and Customs EnforcementFY2018<$1M0.0%11
Hurricane SandyUSCG - Procurement, Construction, & ImprovementFY2017$1M1.4%4
Hurricane SandyS&TFY2017$00.0%3
Intercity Bus Security GrantsFederal Emergency Management AgencyFY2016$1M0.7%7
Port Security Grant ProgramFederal Emergency Management AgencyFY2016$1M0.9%2
Operations and SupportUnited States Customs and Border ProtectionFY2016<$1M0.0%2
Hurricane SandyOIGFY2016<$1M1.8%3
Hurricane SandyDNDOFY2016$00.0%2
Individuals and Households ProgramFEMAFY2015$2M7.0%9
Hurricane SandyCBPFY2015<$1M0.2%2
Hurricane SandyFEMA - Hazard Mitigation Grant ProgramFY2015$00.0%2
Hurricane SandyNPPDFY2015$00.0%2
Emergency Food & Shelter ProgramFederal Emergency Management AgencyFY2014$2M1.5%4
Hurricane SandyFEMA - PayrollFY2014$2M0.6%1
Hurricane SandyFEMA - Purchase and Fleet CardFY2014<$1M8.0%1
Hurricane SandyFEMA - TravelFY2014<$1M0.1%1
Disaster Case ManagementFederal Emergency Management AgencyFY2014$00.0%1
Urban Search and RescueFederal Emergency Management AgencyFY2014$00.0%1
Border Security FencingUnited States Customs and Border ProtectionFY2013$00.0%4
Disaster Relief Fund: Vendor PaymentsFEMAFY2011$17M2.9%6
Payroll: MilitaryUnited States Coast GuardFY2011$4M0.1%4
Payroll, Compensation, & BenefitsTransportation Security AdministrationFY2011$00.0%3
Homeland Security InvestigationsImmigration and Customs EnforcementFY2008$4M1.8%1
Contract PaymentsUSCGFY2008$00.0%1

Did it follow the payment-integrity law?

171819202324

Red = rated out of compliance by its inspector general that fiscal year. Green = compliant.

Overpayments flagged and recovered

YearFlagged to recoverRecovered
FY2025$46M$102M
FY2024$76M$25M
FY2023$205M$8M
FY2022$496M$144M
FY2021$79M$37M
FY2020$72M$65M
FY2019$9M$5M
FY2018$9M$9M
FY2017$30M$30M
FY2016$4M$4M
FY2015$5M$4M
FY2014$6M$6M
FY2013$4M$4M
FY2012<$1M<$1M
FY2011$4M<$1M
FY2010<$1M<$1M
FY2009<$1M<$1M

Sources

  1. FY2025 improper payments dataset: every program's results, root causes, recoveries and compliance (FY2004–FY2025)PaymentAccuracy.gov (OMB and CFO Council); totals summed by FraudBad · Nov 9, 2026
  2. Agencies & programs: improper payment rates, FY2025PaymentAccuracy.gov · accessed Nov 9, 2026

America.co · The RECEIPTS Act

Want to stop it?Sign the Receipts Act.

Public money should come with a receipt anyone can check. The RECEIPTS Act starts with one rule for federal purchases over $25,000 from GSA's buying catalog: publish the price paid next to what other agencies paid for the same thing.

Sign the Receipts Act ↗

A citizen-authored working draft hosted on America.co. It has not been introduced in Congress.