FraudBadNo taxation without receipts

Department of the Treasury · Internal Revenue Service

American Opportunity Tax Credit

In fiscal 2025, this program paid $1.5B wrong or without proof — 30.7% of $5.0B it paid out. That ranks #17 of 64 programs that reported.

$12.9Bpaid wrong or without proof, FY2019–FY2025 (our sum)
30.7%error rate in fiscal 2025
7years of results on record

Paid wrong, year by year

YearPaid outWrong or unprovenOf that, can't tellRate
FY2025$5.0B$1.5B—30.7%
FY2024$5.2B$1.4B—27.7%
FY2023$5.2B$1.7B—31.6%
FY2022$5.6B$2.0B—36.1%
FY2021$7.1B$1.9B—26.3%
FY2020$8.9B$2.3B—26.0%
FY2019$7.9B$2.1B—26.0%

"Can't tell" means the agency couldn't prove the payment right or wrong. All amounts are the agency's own estimates.

Department of the Treasury was rated out of compliance with the payment-integrity law for fiscal 2024. Every Treasury program →

Improper payments include mistakes and missing paperwork as well as fraud. This page shows how much, not why in any one case.

Sources

  1. FY2025 improper payments dataset: every program's results, root causes, recoveries and compliance (FY2004–FY2025)PaymentAccuracy.gov (OMB and CFO Council); totals summed by FraudBad · Nov 9, 2026
  2. Agencies & programs: improper payment rates, FY2025PaymentAccuracy.gov · accessed Nov 9, 2026

America.co · The RECEIPTS Act

Want to stop it?Sign the Receipts Act.

Public money should come with a receipt anyone can check. The RECEIPTS Act starts with one rule for federal purchases over $25,000 from GSA's buying catalog: publish the price paid next to what other agencies paid for the same thing.

Sign the Receipts Act ↗

A citizen-authored working draft hosted on America.co. It has not been introduced in Congress.