FraudBadNo taxation without receipts

State

New York

In fiscal 2025, New York got 13.18% of its food-benefit (SNAP) payments wrong — #8 of 51, where #1 is worst. The national rate was 10.62%.

13.18%of SNAP benefits paid in the wrong amount, fiscal 2025, down 0.91 points from 14.09% in fiscal 2024USDA
$263.9Bin federal awards to recipients in New York, fiscal 2025USAspending.gov
$13,286per resident (our math: awards ÷ 19,867,248 people)USAspending.gov · Census

Food benefits paid wrong

Fiscal yearPaid too muchPaid too littleError rate
202512.06%1.12%13.18%
2024——14.09%

USDA measures errors over a small tolerance ($57 per case in fiscal 2025). An error is not the same as fraud: the rate counts paying too much and too little.

What New York's auditors found

$23,190Vocational rehabilitation · counted by the auditors

The audit's only dollar finding: $23,190 in vocational rehabilitation spending that fell outside the grant period.

KPMG LLP: State of New York single audit, fiscal year ended Mar 31, 2025, finding 2025-003. Filed Dec 30, 2025. How we picked this.

Unemployment benefits paid wrong

21.82%of unemployment benefits overpaid or underpaid · #5 of 51, #1 worst

In the 12 months ending March 31, 2026, New York paid 21.82% of its unemployment benefits in the wrong amount, down from 31.17% a year earlier. The national rate was 12.11%. The federal goal is under 10%; New York is above it.

The same sample found 14.17% of benefits went out on payments the Labor Department counts as fraud (national: 4.00%).

12 monthsPaid wrongFraud
Apr 2025 – Mar 202621.82%14.17%
Apr 2024 – Mar 202531.17%22.12%

The Labor Department checks a random sample of each state's payments every year (its Benefit Accuracy Measurement program). Like the SNAP rate, "paid wrong" counts paying too much and too little.

Sources

  1. SNAP payment error rates, fiscal year 2025 (by state)USDA Food and Nutrition Service · Jun 24, 2026
  2. SNAP payment error rates, fiscal year 2024 (by state)USDA Food and Nutrition Service · Jun 30, 2025
  3. UI State Performance Scorecard: improper payment and fraud rates, 12 months ending Mar 31, 2026 and 2025U.S. Department of Labor, Employment and Training Administration · pulled Nov 10, 2026
  4. State profiles: federal prime awards to recipients in each state, fiscal year 2025USAspending.gov (U.S. Treasury), pulled by FraudBad · Nov 10, 2026
  5. State population totals, vintage 2024 (NST-EST2024)U.S. Census Bureau · Dec 2024
  6. State of New York single audit, fiscal year ended Mar 31, 2025KPMG LLP · Dec 30, 2025

America.co · The RECEIPTS Act

Want to stop it?Sign the Receipts Act.

Public money should come with a receipt anyone can check. The RECEIPTS Act starts with one rule for federal purchases over $25,000 from GSA's buying catalog: publish the price paid next to what other agencies paid for the same thing.

Sign the Receipts Act ↗

A citizen-authored working draft hosted on America.co. It has not been introduced in Congress.