State
New York
In fiscal 2025, New York got 13.18% of its food-benefit (SNAP) payments wrong — #8 of 51, where #1 is worst. The national rate was 10.62%.
Food benefits paid wrong
| Fiscal year | Paid too much | Paid too little | Error rate |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2025 | 12.06% | 1.12% | 13.18% |
| 2024 | — | — | 14.09% |
USDA measures errors over a small tolerance ($57 per case in fiscal 2025). An error is not the same as fraud: the rate counts paying too much and too little.
What New York's auditors found
$23,190Vocational rehabilitation · counted by the auditors
The audit's only dollar finding: $23,190 in vocational rehabilitation spending that fell outside the grant period.
KPMG LLP: State of New York single audit, fiscal year ended Mar 31, 2025, finding 2025-003. Filed Dec 30, 2025. How we picked this.
Unemployment benefits paid wrong
21.82%of unemployment benefits overpaid or underpaid · #5 of 51, #1 worst
In the 12 months ending March 31, 2026, New York paid 21.82% of its unemployment benefits in the wrong amount, down from 31.17% a year earlier. The national rate was 12.11%. The federal goal is under 10%; New York is above it.
The same sample found 14.17% of benefits went out on payments the Labor Department counts as fraud (national: 4.00%).
| 12 months | Paid wrong | Fraud |
|---|---|---|
| Apr 2025 – Mar 2026 | 21.82% | 14.17% |
| Apr 2024 – Mar 2025 | 31.17% | 22.12% |
The Labor Department checks a random sample of each state's payments every year (its Benefit Accuracy Measurement program). Like the SNAP rate, "paid wrong" counts paying too much and too little.
Sources
- SNAP payment error rates, fiscal year 2025 (by state)USDA Food and Nutrition Service · Jun 24, 2026
- SNAP payment error rates, fiscal year 2024 (by state)USDA Food and Nutrition Service · Jun 30, 2025
- UI State Performance Scorecard: improper payment and fraud rates, 12 months ending Mar 31, 2026 and 2025U.S. Department of Labor, Employment and Training Administration · pulled Nov 10, 2026
- State profiles: federal prime awards to recipients in each state, fiscal year 2025USAspending.gov (U.S. Treasury), pulled by FraudBad · Nov 10, 2026
- State population totals, vintage 2024 (NST-EST2024)U.S. Census Bureau · Dec 2024
- State of New York single audit, fiscal year ended Mar 31, 2025KPMG LLP · Dec 30, 2025